Mendelsohn's Pizza, Brooklyn | Menu | Reviews

Discovering the Authentic Taste of Mendelsohn's Pizza

Located in the heart of Brooklyn at 4418 18th Ave, Mendelsohn's Pizza has long served as a cornerstone for those seeking a genuine and comforting dining experience. In a city defined by its fast-paced lifestyle and endless culinary options, this establishment stands out by focusing on the fundamentals of quality preparation and a welcoming atmosphere. Whether you are a local resident or someone visiting the vibrant neighborhood of Brooklyn, the restaurant offers a space where the simple pleasure of a well-made meal takes center stage.

The philosophy behind Mendelsohn's Pizza is rooted in consistency and respect for traditional techniques. Rather than chasing fleeting food trends, the kitchen prioritizes the integrity of ingredients and the patience required to achieve the perfect balance of textures. Every aspect of the operation is designed to ensure that guests feel at home, making it a preferred destination for families, friends, and individuals looking for a reliable spot to enjoy a slice or a full pie in a relaxed setting.

What Makes Mendelsohn's Pizza a Local Favorite

Commitment to Quality Ingredients: The kitchen places a high value on sourcing components that meet rigorous standards, ensuring that every bite reflects a dedication to freshness and flavor profiles that resonate with the palate.
A Welcoming Neighborhood Atmosphere: Situated conveniently on 18th Avenue, the restaurant serves as a community hub where the environment is intentionally kept unpretentious and inviting, fostering a sense of belonging for all patrons.
Time-Honored Preparation Methods: By adhering to proven culinary practices, the staff ensures that the crust, sauce, and toppings harmonize perfectly, delivering a classic experience that honors the history of pizza-making in New York.
Reliable Service and Consistency: Guests frequently return because they know exactly what to expect: a high-quality meal served with care, maintaining the same standard of excellence regardless of how busy the day might be.

The appeal of Mendelsohn's Pizza lies in its ability to remain grounded while serving a diverse and discerning clientele. It is not merely about the food itself, but about the role the restaurant plays in the daily lives of those who live and work in the area. By maintaining a focus on what truly matters—great taste, a comfortable environment, and a friendly staff—the establishment has secured its place as a staple of the Brooklyn food scene.

As you explore the various culinary offerings throughout New York, finding a place that feels authentic and honest is a rewarding experience. Mendelsohn's Pizza invites you to step away from the noise of the city and enjoy a meal that prioritizes quality above all else. Whether you are stopping by for a quick lunch or settling in for an evening meal, you will find that the dedication to the craft is evident in every detail. We look forward to welcoming you to our location on 18th Avenue, where the tradition of great pizza continues to thrive.

Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Wheelchair accessible seating
Service options
- Onsite services
- Takeout
- Dine-in
- Delivery
Highlights
- Fast service
- Great coffee
- Great tea selection
- Serves local specialty
Popular for
- Breakfast
- Lunch
- Solo dining
Offerings
- Coffee
- Comfort food
- Healthy options
- Quick bite
- Vegetarian options
Dining options
- Breakfast
- Brunch
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Dessert
- Seating
- Table service
Amenities
- Restroom
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cozy
Crowd
- College students
- Family-friendly
- Tourists
Planning
- Accepts reservations
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
Children
- Good for kids
- High chairs
- Kids' menu
Parking
- Paid parking garage
- Paid parking lot
- Paid street parking
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Wheelchair accessible seating
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Service options
- Delivery
- Onsite services
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Highlights
- Great coffee
- Serves local specialty
Popular for
- Breakfast
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Offerings
- Coffee
- Comfort food
- Healthy options
- Quick bite
- Salad bar
- Small plates
- Vegan options
- Vegetarian options
Dining options
- Breakfast
- Brunch
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Catering
- Counter service
- Dessert
- Seating
- Table service
Amenities
- Restroom
Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy
Crowd
- College students
- Family-friendly
- Groups
- Tourists
Planning
- Accepts reservations
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids
- Good for kids birthday
- High chairs
- Kids' menu
Parking
- Free street parking
- Paid street parking
- Usually somewhat difficult to find a space
Pets
- Dogs allowed
- Dogs allowed inside
- Dogs allowed outside

Fresh Crispy Salads
- Garden Salad
- Soup & Salad $7.00
- Chef Salad
- Lickin Chicken Salad $8.00
- Tuna Salad
- Low Country Shrimp Salad
- Thunderbird Salad
- Portabella Mushroom Salad
PIZZA*
- Pizza Dough $10.00
- Pizza Wrap $12.50
- Pizza Sauce Jar $9.99
- 12" Sourdough Pizza $18.99
SLICE
- Regular Slice $4.25
- Extra Cheese Slice $4.95
- Whole Wheat Slice $4.95
- Broccoli Slice $4.95
- Olive Slice $4.95
- Tomato Slice $4.95
- Mushroom Slice $4.95
- Mushroom Onion Slice $4.95
- Fried Onion Slice $4.95
- Eggplant Slice $4.95
- Spinach Vegetable Slice $4.95
- Vegetable Slice $4.95
- Everything Slice $4.95
- Cheeseless Vegetable Slice $4.95
- Fresh Mozzarella Slice $4.95
- Baked Zitti Slice $4.95
- Spicy Fries Slice $4.95
- Square Slice $4.95
- Regular Pan Slice $5.50
- Vegetable Pan Slice $5.50
- Chicago Slice $7.99
- Regular Fries Slice $4.95
PIE
- Regular Pie $28.50
- Extra Cheese Pie $33.50
- Whole Wheat Pie $33.50
- Broccoli Pie $33.50
- Olive Pie $33.50
- Tomato Pie $33.50
- Mushroom Pie $33.50
- Mushroom Onion Pie $33.50
- Fried Onion Pie $33.50
- Eggplant Pie $33.50
- Spinach Vegetable Pie $33.50
- Vegetable Pie $33.50
- Everything Pie $33.50
- Cheeseless Vegetable Pie $33.50
- Fresh Mozzarella Pie $33.50
- Penne Pie $33.50
- Spicy Fries Pie $33.50
- Square Pie $66.00
- Regular Pan Pie $33.50
- Vegetable Pan Pie $33.50
- Chicago Pie $52.00
- Regular Pie Cut 16 $28.50
- Whole Whwat Wrap Pie $12.50
FRENCH FRIES
- French Fries $8.50
- Cheese Fries $9.75
- Onion Rings $9.50
- 9 X 13 French Fries $40.00
CALZONES & KNISHES
- Cheese Calzone $9.00
- Mushroom Calzone $9.00
- Vegetable Calzone $9.00
- Broccoli Calzone $9.00
- Cheese Pretzel $9.00
- Cheese Horn / Stick $9.00
- Knish $5.40
- Pizza Knish $6.00
- Moms Knish $6.00
SALADS & PLATES
- Create Romaine Salad $14.50
- Create Iceberg Salad $14.50
- American Salad $14.50
- Avocado Salad $14.50
- Broccoli Salad $10.95
- Caesar Salad $14.50
- Greek Salad $14.50
- Grilled Vegetable Salad $14.50
- Israeli Salad $8.00
- Sauerkraut $6.00
- Garden Salad $14.50
- Tahina $0.50
- Tuna Plate $11.99
SIDES & APPETIZERS
- Baked Potato With Broccoli & Cheese $7.95
- Cheese Blintz $4.00
- Vegetable Cutlet $5.95
- Mashed Potatoes $9.95
- Roasted Potatoes $9.00
- Rice $9.00
- Chinese Vegetables $9.95
- Steamed Vegetables $9.95
- Mozerella Sticks $3.25
- 1 Garlic Knots $1.00
- 4 Garlic Knots With Cheese And Sauce $7.50
- Potato Latkes $4.25
PASTA & MAINS
- Baked Ziti $10.95
- Diet Zucchini Soufflé $10.95
- Eggplant Parmesan $10.95
- Eggplant Spinach Roll $13.95
- Fettuccine Alfredo $10.95
- Lasagna $10.95
- Lasagna Spinach Roll $13.95
- Mac N Cheese $10.95
- Pasta Of The Day $10.95
- Vegetable Lasagna $10.95
FISH DISHES
- Salmon $15.95
- Salmon W/Side $19.99
- Tilapia $11.95
- Tilapia W/Side $17.95
- Fish N Chips $15.95
SOUPS
- Vegetable Soup $7.50
- Split Pea Soup $7.50
- Mushroom Barley Soup $7.50
- Soup Of The Day $7.50
FALAFEL
- (4) Falafel Balls $4.50
- Falafel Platter $12.00
- Falafel Pita $8.75
- Falafel Balls, Sauerkraut & Tehina $7.50
- Sauerkraut $6.00
- Tehina $0.50
- Plain Pita $1.00
PANINIS & WRAPS
- Create Panini Or Wrap $12.50
- Avocado Panini / Wrap $12.50
- Classic Tuna Melt $12.50
- Egg Salad Panini / Wrap $10.50
- Grilled Cheese Panini / Wrap $12.50
- Grilled Vegetable Panini / Wrap $12.50
- Italian Panini / Wrap $12.50
- Mediterranean Panini /Wrap $12.50
- Pizza Panini / Wrap $12.50
- Pizza Wrap Pie $12.50
- Portobello Panini / Wrap $12.50
- Tuna Panini / Wrap $11.00
- Avocado Wrap $11.00
SANDWICHES
- Butter Sandwich $4.25
- Cream Cheese Sandwich $6.50
- Tuna Sandwich $8.95
- Egg Omelet Sandwich $9.00
- Egg Salad Sandwich $7.25
- Plain Bread $1.00
ICE CREAM
- Cone $6.25
- Ice Cream Cup $6.25
- Milk Shake $9.00
- Razzle $10.50
GRAB & GO
- Gluten Free Penne Pasta $13.99
- Gluten Free Baked Ziti $13.99
- Gluten Free Mac & Cheese $13.99
- Fruit Cup $4.99
- Muesli Cup $5.99
- Black Olive Pate $5.99
- Onion Pate $5.99
- Green Olive Pate $5.99
- Mushroom Pate $5.99
- 18" Frozen Pizza $14.99
SAUCES
- Alfredo Sauce $10.00
- Penne Sauce $10.00
- Pizza Sauce $10.00
- Pizza Margarita Sauce $10.00
- Pesto Cream Sauce $10.00
- Mac & Cheese Sauce $10.00
- Marinera Sauce $10.00
SUSHI APPS
- A1 Spicy Kani Salad $14.95
- A2 Sushi Nigiri Appetizer, 2 Salmon ,2 Tuna $12.00
- A3 Spicy Tuna Tartar $13.00
- A4 Kani Parpar ,Served On A Bed Of Sushi Rice $13.00
- Poki Bowl $16.50
VEGETABLE ROLL
- B1 Fancy Vegetable Roll,Avcado On Top With Avcado Cucumber,Carrot Inside $10.50
- B3 Avocado Roll $8.50
- B2 Cucumber Roll $6.50
- B4 Cucumber & Avocado Roll $8.50
- B5 Vegetable Roll $8.50
- B6 Sweet Potato Roll $7.50
- B7 Peanut Avocado Roll $8.50
- B8 Tropical Roll $8.50
- B9 Garden Vegetable Roll $8.50
- B10 Hawaii Roll $8.50
- B11 Fried Onion Avocado Roll $8.50
- B12 Futomaki Roll $10.00
- B13 Oshinko Roll $10.50
- B14 Cucum Skin Vegetable Roll $10.00
- B15 Bello Cucumber Roll $10.50
SUSHI ROLL & HAND ROLL
- C1 Tuna Avocado $11.00
- C2 Salmon Cucumber $10.50
- C3 Spicy Salmon Avocado Crunch $10.50
- C4 Spicy Tuna Cucumber Crunch $11.00
- C5 California Roll $8.50
- C6 Alaska Roll $10.50
- C7 Salmon Avocado $10.50
- C8 Spicy Kani Crunch $9.00
- C9 Cherry Blossom $11.00
- C10 Black Pepper Tuna Cucumber $11.00
- C11 Yellow Tail Avocado $11.00
- C12 Smoked Green Dragon Roll $13.00
- C13 Boston Roll $8.50
- C14 Firehouse $14.00
- C15 Fire Hydrant $14.00
- C16 California Dragon $12.00
- C17 Philadelphia Roll $9.50
- C18 Salmon Skin Roll $10.00
- C19 Mushroom Avocado Roll $10.00
- Rice Roll $7.50
COOKED FISH ROLL
- D1 Cooked Salmon Avocado $10.50
- D2 Cooked Tuna Avocado $12.00
- D3 Cooked Kani Cucumber $8.50
- D4 Cooked Smoked Salmon & Cucumber $10.50
- D5 Cooked Yellowtail Avocado $10.50
- D6 Cooked Ranibow Roll $14.00
- D7 Cooked Cucumber Skin Roll $13.00
- D8 Cooked Jumbo Roll $15.50
CHEF'S SPECIAL ROLL
- F1 King Rafie Roll $13.50
- F2 Volcano Roll $14.00
- F3 Rainbow Roll $14.50
- F4 Red Dragon Roll $14.50
- F5 Sweet Heart Roll $15.00
- F6 18th Ave Roll $14.00
- F7 Fantastic Roll $15.00
- F8 Dynamite Roll $15.00
- F9 Explosive Material Roll $15.00
- F10 Caterpillar Roll $13.00
- F11 Fuji Mountain Roll $15.00
WHOLE TEMPURA ROLL
- H1 Spider Roll $13.00
- H2 Manhattan Roll $15.00
- H3 Crazy Salmon Tempura Roll $14.00
- H4 Godzilla Roll $14.00
- H5 King Kong Roll $15.00
- H6 Smoked Salmon Tempura $13.00
- H7 California Tempura Roll $11.00
- H8 Sweet Potato Tempura $9.50
SUSHI PLATTER
- J1 Small Platter,8 Rolls 70pcs $85.00
- J2 Large Platter, 13rolls, 110pcs $125.00
- J3 Vegetable Platter,8 Rolls 70pcs $70.00
- J4 Vegetable Platter, 13 Rolls 110pcs $95.00
DRINKS
- Fountain Soda
- Bottled Water $1.50
- Can Soda $2.25
- Snapple $3.00
- 20 Onz Soda $3.00
- 1 Liter Soda $4.00
- 2 Liters Soda $5.25
- Orange Juice $4.00
- Ice Coffee $3.75
- Coffee
- Tea
- Hot Coco
- Pareve Smoothie
- Dairy Smoothie
- Gatorade $3.00
- Vitamin Water $4.00
Specialty Drink
- Hot Cappuccino
- Hot Latte
- Hot Americano
- Espresso Shot
Flavored Lattes
- Hot Cafe Mocha Latte
- Hot White Mocha Latte
- Hot Carmel Macchiato Latte
- Hot Nutella Latte
Hot Drink
- Hot Chocolate
- Hot White Chocolate
- Hot Chai
- Hot Peanut Butter Cup
Iced Drinks
- Iced Latte $7.50
- Iced Mocha $7.50
- Iced White Mocha $7.50
- Iced Carmel Macchiato $7.50
Frappes Drink
- Cappuccino Frappe $9.49
- Toffee Carmel Frappe $9.49
- Mocha Frappe $9.49
- Halva Frappe $9.49
Specialty Milkshakes
- Halva $9.49
- Oreo Blast $9.49
- Salty Peanut Pretzel $9.49
- Ferrero Crunch $9.49
Fruit Shakes
- Mixed Berries $9.49
- Strawberry Banana $9.49
- Tropical $9.49
Smoothies
- TROPIC TANGO $7.50
- SPLENDID SUPERFRUIT $7.50
- BERRY BLAST $7.50
PIZZA
- Pizza Dough $10.00
- Pizza Sauce Jar $9.99
SLICE
- Regular Slice $4.25
PIE
- Regular Pie $28.50
- Regular Pie Cut 16 $28.50
CALZONES & KNISHES
- Cheese Calzone $9.00
- Mushroom Calzone $9.00
- Vegetable Calzone $9.00
- Broccoli Calzone $9.00
- Cheese Pretzel $9.00
- Cheese Horn / Stick $9.00
- Knish $5.40
SIDES & APPETIZERS
- Cheese Blintz $4.00
- Mozerella Sticks $3.25
- 1 Garlic Knots $1.00
PASTA & MAINS
- Baked Ziti $10.95
- Fettuccine Alfredo $10.95
- Lasagna $10.95
- Mac N Cheese $10.95
- Eggplant Parmesan
FALAFEL
- (4) Falafel Balls $4.50
- Falafel Pita $8.75
- Falafel Balls, Sauerkraut & Tehina $7.50
COOKED FISH ROLL
- D1 Cooked Salmon Avocado $10.50
- D2 Cooked Tuna Avocado $12.00
- D3 Cooked Kani Cucumber $8.50
- D4 Cooked Smoked Salmon & Cucumber $10.50
- D5 Cooked Yellowtail Avocado $10.50
- D6 Cooked Ranibow Roll $14.00
- D7 Cooked Cucumber Skin Roll $13.00
- D8 Cooked Jumbo Roll $15.50
- D9 Sweetheart Roll $14.50
DRINKS
- Fountain Soda
- Bottled Water $1.99
- Can Soda $1.99
- Snapple $2.50
- 20 Onz Soda $2.50
- 1 Liter Soda $3.75
- 2 Liters Soda $4.75
- Ice Coffee $3.50
- Coffee
- Tea
- Hot Coco
- Pareve Smoothie
- Dairy Smoothie
- Vitaminwater $4.00
- Gatorade $2.50

Tiffany Sztojka

23-04-2026

THERE WAS A NAIL IN MY PIZZA CRUST NO ONE PICKS UP THE PHONE THIS IS DISGUSTING Order type Delivery

23-04-2026

Too sloppy Order type Take out Food: 1 Service: 3

Chaya vaturi חיוש המושלמת

23-04-2026

Disgusting food, not clean don’t recommend Order type Dine in Meal type Other Price per person $10–20 Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1 Group size 3-4 people

Philip Levinson

23-04-2026

Great pizza I don't like what they did to the place, I flet extremely uncomfortable sitting there. I the past it was wonderful spacious place, now they cut the place in 2 and all the tables are way to close to each other Order type Dine in Meal type Lunch Price per person $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 1

ALPHA FIT

23-04-2026

By far the best pizza place in Borough Park!!! A lot of healthy options like grilled fish, whole wheat pizza, sushi, salads..... tastes great. My family and friends go there all the time. Clean and courteous service. More